Thursday, September 5, 2013

Scan of Hindi Discourse Containing Critical Distortion

The below are scanned images of the first page of the printed discourse from "Kevala Bhakti", Ananda Vacanamrtam vol 20 (Hindi Edition), 1994. The second and third sentences on this page are critically distorted from what Bábá actually said on the recording of the discourse.  
 
Bábá says on the recording that “In collective life the creation will never come to an end.” In place of this very sentence, our AMPS Publishers wrote instead that, “In social life, laziness should be destroyed—of course it will be destroyed.”

Bábá's direct words in Hindi are:

"सामूहिक जीवन में सृष्टि का ख़ातमा कभी नहीं होगा | ख़ातमा क्यों नहीं होगा, इसके पीछे भी दो कारण हैं | एक logical cum scientific और एक है sentimental |

Whereas the Kolkata Publishers printed the following words instead:

"सामाजिक जीवन में आलस्य का विनाश करना चाहिए विनाश क्यों नहीं होगा ? इसके पीछे भी दो कारण हैं एक तर्क सम्मत वैज्ञानिक और दूसरा भावात्मक तर्क सम्मत |"

These are two scans of the same page. The left one is exactly as found in the printed book. The right one has a red line underlining the extremely critical distortion; the blue line underscores a distortion which is also important although not as critical. Click on the below scanned images, and they will enlarge and become quite clear to read. (The second and third sentences on the page are the critical ones cited above.)